Skip to main content

Table 2 Overview of main psychological therapies for the management of low weight anorexia nervosa, bulimia nervosa and binge-eating disorder

From: Management of eating disorders for people with higher weight: clinical practice guideline

 

CBT-E/CBT-ANa [143, 311]

MANTRA [312]

SSCM [313]

FPT [99]

IPT [100]

FBT/FT-AN [50, 51]

DBT [101]

Eating disorder indicated evidence base for use

Adults, Older adolescents Transdiagnostic/Adults with anorexia nervosa

Adults with anorexia nervosa

Adults with anorexia nervosa

Adults with anorexia nervosa

Adults with bulimia nervosa and BED

Children and adolescents with anorexia nervosa and bulimia nervosa

Adults with bulimia nervosa and BED

Theoretical model

CBT formulation & in CBT-E transdiagnostic maintaining factors

Cognitive/Interpersonal

Atheoretical

Psychodynamic formulation

Interpersonal function’s bidirectional relationship with bulimia nervosa/BED symptoms mediated by self-esteem & negative affect

Atheoretical ‘agnostic’

Understanding the dialectic of opposing views of eating disorder behaviours and their use in distress reduction

Targets

Dysfunctional eating, weight/shape (body dissatisfaction) beliefs, disordered eating

Intra- and interpersonal maintaining factors, e.g., inflexibility

Undernutrition, other ‘targets’ as personalised goals

Intra- and interpersonal maintaining factors, e.g., low self-esteem

Interpersonal (IP) problem areas: Grief, Role transitions, Role disputes, IP sensitivities

Food restriction and family eating; Other family/adolescent issues

Learning skills in:

mindfulness;

distress tolerance;

emotion regulation; & interpersonal effectiveness

Therapy tools

Behavioural monitoring, behavioural experiments, cognitive restructuring, chain analyses

Motivational interviewing, social integration, cognitive remediation

Psychoeducation, goal-directed and supportive therapy

Exploration of beliefs/schema, interpersonal therapy, goal setting, new behaviours

Exploration of interpersonal function and eating disorder, encouraging affect, clarification, communication analysis, therapeutic relationship

Psychoeducation, externalisation of the eating disorder, family meals with initial parental empowerment to progressing to age-appropriate independent eating

Training in emotion regulation skills; ‘meaning making’ as acceptance and change; validating the worth of the individual

Mood symptoms

Core mood intolerance module in CBT-E

Emotion skills training

Symptom management

Exploration/analysis of affective-emotional experiences

Encouraging affect: acceptance; effective communication of affect; experience suppressed affects

Symptom management

Addressed through emotion regulation skills and other training

  1. The Table is adapted from Table 2 in Hay, P. (2020). Current approach to eating disorders: A clinical update. Internal Medicine Journal, 50(1), Reproduced with permission of the author (Open Access copyright)
  2. BED = binge-eating disorder; CBT-E = cognitive behaviour therapy-enhanced; CBT-AN = cognitive behaviour therapy-for anorexia nervosa; MANTRA = Maudsley model of anorexia nervosa treatment for adults; SSCM = specialist supportive clinical management; FPT = focal psychodynamic therapy; IPT = interpersonal psychotherapy; FBT = family based treatment; FT-AN = Family Therapy for Anorexia Nervosa; DBT = Dialectical Behaviour Therapy
  3. It was beyond the scope to include all the psychological therapies with emerging evidence for the treatment of eating disorders e.g. Integrated cognitive affective therapy [ICAT; ] and readers should not take this as an exhaustive list
  4. aCBT In Guided Self-Help (CBTgsh) forms are effective for bulimia nervosa and BED