Skip to main content

Table 2 Compulsive exercise test scores at baseline (T1), post-treatment (T2), 6 months (T3) and 12 months (T4) follow-up

From: Treatment effects on compulsive exercise and physical activity in eating disorders

 

T1 CI .99

T2 CI .99

T3 CI .99

T4 CI .99

Within effects, p-value, Effect size (g)

Between effects, p-value, Effect size (g)

T2

T3

T4

T2

T3

T4

CET total

 PED-t

14.43 13.61–15.26

13.14 12.27–14.02

12.81 11.92–13.69

12.59 11.70–13.47

< .001

g = 0.49

<.001

g = 0.63

<.001

g = 0.63

   

 CBT

14.21 13.37–15.04

13.12 12.19–14.05

13.27 12.28–14.26

12.87 11.86–13.87

<.001

g = 0.41

.007

g = 0.44

<.001

g = 0.61

n.s.

n.s.

n.s.

 CONTROL

15.18 13.66–16.68

14.63 13.02–16.24

n.s.

  

n.s.

  

CET avoidance

 PED-t

2.34 1.99–2.69

1.84 1.47–2.21

1.73 1.36–2.11

1.62 1.25–1.99

<.001

g = 0.28

<.001

g = 0.33

<.001

g = 0.39

   

 CBT

2.72 1.92–2.63

1.89 1.50–2.69

1.88 1.47–2.30

1.75 1.33–2.17

.003

g = 0.24

.005

g = 0.25

<.001

g = 0.41

n.s.

n.s.

n.s.

 CONTROL

2.72 2.23–3.20

2.56 1.88–3.24

n.s.

  

n.s.

  

CET weight control

 PED-t

3.32

3.04–3.61

2.57 2.26–.2.87

2.71 2.40–3.02

2.64 2.33–2.95

<.001

g = 0.57

<.001

g = 0.41

<.001

g = 0.49

   

 CBT

3.34

3.05–3.63

2.96 2.63–3.29

3.09 2.73–3.44

2.80 2.44–3.15

.002

g = 0.33

n.s.

<.001

g = 0.49

n.s.

n.s.

n.s.

 CONTROL

3.66

3.26–4.05

3.31 2.75–3.87

n.s.

  

n.s.

  

CET mood

 PED-t

4.22

3.97–4.47

4.23

3.96–4.50

4.09 3.82–4.35

3.96 3.69–4.22

n.s.

n.s.

0.008

g = 0.30

   

 CBT

4.11

3.86–4.36

4.08 3.79–4.36

4.01 3.70–4.32

4.07 3.75–4.38

n.s.

n.s.

n.s.

n.s.

n.s.

n.s.

 CONTROL

4.23

3.77–4.68

4.27 3.78–4.76

n.s.

  

n.s.

  

CET lack of enjoy.

 PED-t

1.57

1.24–1.90

1.34 0.99–1.69

1.43 1.08–1.79

1.51 1.16–1.86

n.s.

n.s.

n.s.

   

 CBT

1.64

1.30–1.98

1.46 1.09–1.83

1.69 1.30–2.08

1.56 1.17–1.96

n.s.

n.s.

n.s.

n.s.

n.s.

n.s.

 CONTROL

1.34

0.73–1.95

1.41 0.77–2.06

n.s.

  

n.s.

  

CET rigidity

 PED-t

2.91

2.59–3.24

3.17

2.82–3.52

2.86

2.51–3.21

2.86

2.50–3.21

n.s.

n.s.

n.s.

   

 CBT

2.85

2.52–3.19

2.74

2.36–3.11

2.60

2.20–3.00

2.70

2.29–3.11

n.s.

n.s.

n.s.

n.s.

n.s.

n.s.

 CONTROL

3.23

2.63–3.82

3.10

2.45–3.74

n.s.

  

n.s.

  
  1. NOTES: PED-t Physical exercise and Dietary therapy, CBT Cognitive Behavior Therapy, CI .99 99% confidence interval. Within = Change from baseline to any of the three posttests (T2, T3 and T4); Between = Difference between groups (adjusted for baseline) at any of the three posttests (T2, T3 and T4); g, effect size of Hedges ‘g; n.s., non-significant
  2. Significance in bold is defined when p < 0.01