Skip to main content

Table 1 CBT+ vs. DBT-BED Comparison of Treatment Outcome

From: Dialectical behavior therapy adapted for binge eating compared to cognitive behavior therapy in obese adults with binge eating disorder: a controlled study

Outcome Group   Study Visit (mean, SD) CBT+ vs. DBT-BED
N EOT FU
  Baseline EOT FU Sig. d SRD Sig. d SRD
EDE-Q Globala CBT+ 33 3.06 (1.10) 1.64 (1.16) 1.61 (1.11) .060 .45 .248 .020 .55 .302
DBT-BED 41 3.48 (0.79) 2.31 (1.09) 2.35 (1.06)
OBE Episodesa CBT+ 33 8.27 (9.65) 0.74 (1.68) 1.85 (5.11) .035 .46 .253 .095 .37 .204
DBT-BED 41 7.51 (8.72) 1.64 (3.77) 2.75 (5.58)
DEBQ Emotional
Eatingb
CBT+ 33 3.76 (0.69) 2.55 (0.64) 2.45 (0.86) .322 .23 .128 .196 .29 .161
DBT-BED 41 3.77 (0.68) 2.72 (0.64) 2.73 (0.83)
EDI-3 Emotional
Dysregulationb
CBT+ 33 25.09 (6.80) 21.84 (3.72) 21.23 (4.61) .392 .21 .117 .253 .27 .150
DBT-BED 41 27.02 (5.93) 23.81 (6.74) 22.88 (3.76)
SCL-90b CBT+ 33 175.5 (51.9) 136.0 (39.6) 128.8 (37.1) .257 .27 .150 .152 .34 .188
DBT-BED 41 185.9 (43.1) 150.7 (45.4) 144.3 (38.4)
BDI-IIb CBT+ 33 20.53 (9.89) 7.56 (6.52) 7.21 (6.45) .193 .31 .172 .098 .39 .215
DBT-BED 41 21.98 (7.60) 10.69 (8.46) 10.75 (8.20)
EDI-3 Self-Esteemb CBT+ 33 35.44 (9.00) 25.89 (7.96) 24.12 (8.17) .072 .43 .237 .014 .59 .324
DBT-BED 41 38.32 (8.47) 30.80 (9.64) 29.75 (8.00)
  1. EOT End of treatment, FU Follow-up, d Cohen’s d, SRD Success rate difference
  2. aPrimary outcome measure
  3. bSecondary outcome measure