From: Meta analysis on the efficacy of pharmacotherapy versus placebo on anorexia nervosa
1st Author, Year | Length of RCT | Recruitment | Anorexia type | Treatment conditions | Baseline mean weighta | N | Mean age | Type and dosageb | Setting | Adjunctive treatment | Weight outcome measures | Drop-out |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Attia, 1998 [17] | 7 weeks | Clinical | Restricting/Binge-purge | 1. AD | 73 (IBW) | 15 | 26 | Fluoxetine 60 mg | Inpatient | 1. Individual therapy | 1.% IBW | 27% |
2. Placebo | 72 (IBW) | 16 | 2. Group therapy | 2. Change in % IBW/day | 25% | |||||||
3. Family therapy | ||||||||||||
4. Behavior therapy | ||||||||||||
5. Caloric repletion | ||||||||||||
Attia, 2011 [18] | 8 weeks | Clinical | Restricting/Binge-purge | 1. AP | 16.7 | 11 12 (1 male) | 27.7 | Olanzapine | Outpatient | Â | 1. BMI | 26% |
2. Placebo | 17.4 | 2.5 mg | 25% | |||||||||
5 mg | ||||||||||||
10 mg | ||||||||||||
Bissada, 2008 [19] | 10 weeks | Clinical | Restricting/Binge-purge | 1. AP | 16.39 | 18 | 29.7 | Olanzapine | Day hospital | 1. Meal supervision | 1. BMI | 14% |
2. Placebo | 15.93 | 16 | 23.6 | 2.5 mg | 2. Group therapy | 28% | ||||||
5 mg | ||||||||||||
7.5 mg | ||||||||||||
10 mg | ||||||||||||
Brambilla 2007a [20] | 3 months | Clinical | Unknown | 1. AP | 15.5 | 15 | 23.7 | Olanzapine | Outpatient | 1. CBT | 1. BMI | 14% |
2. Placebo | 15.8 | 15 | 26.3 | 2.5 mg | ||||||||
5 mg | ||||||||||||
Brambilla 2007b [21] | 3 months | Clinical | Restricting/Binge-purge | 1. AP | 15.7 | 10 | 23 | Olanzapine | Outpatient | 1. CBT | 1. BMI | n.m. |
2. Placebo | 16.3 | 10 | Â | 2.5 mg | Â | 2. Nutritional rehabilitation | ||||||
5 mg | ||||||||||||
Di Vasta 2012 [22] | 18 months | Clinical | Restricting/Binge-purge | 1. H | 18.1 | 47 | 18.1 | Dehydroepiandrosterone | Outpatient | 1. Routine care = medical, nutritional, psychological monitoring | 1. Kg | 34% |
2. Placebo | 47 | 50 mg | 2. BMI | 38% | ||||||||
3. Lean mass | ||||||||||||
4. Fat mass | ||||||||||||
1st Author, Year | Length of RCT | Recruitment | Anorexia type | Treatment conditions | Baseline mean weight a | N | Age | Type | Setting | Adjunctive treatments | Weight outcome measures | Drop-out |
Fazeli 2010 [23] | 12 weeks | Community and clinical | Restricting/Binge-purge | 1. GH | 17.4 | 10 | 28 | Nutropin | Outpatient | Â | 1. Kg ch. | 10% |
2. Placebo | 17.2 | 11 | 29.2 | 15 mg | 2.%IBW ch. | 18% | ||||||
3.% lean ch. | ||||||||||||
4. Lean ch. | ||||||||||||
5. Extremity lean ch. | ||||||||||||
6.% fat ch. | ||||||||||||
7. Fat mass ch. | ||||||||||||
8. Trunk fat ch. | ||||||||||||
9. Extremity fat ch. | ||||||||||||
Grinspoon 1996 [24] | 9 months | Clinical | Restricting/ Binge-purge | 1. GH 30 mg | 16.3 | 11 | 23 | Insulin-like growth factor I | Inpatient | Â | 1.%IBW | 0 |
2. GH 100 mg | 17 | 11 | 30 or 100 mg | 2. BMI | 19% | |||||||
3. Placebo | 15.6 | 11 | 9% | |||||||||
Grinspoon 2002 [25] | 6 days | Clinical | Restricting/ Binge-purge | 1. GH + H | 35 kg | 16 | 24.2 | Recombinant human IGF-I + Ovcon | Outpatient | 1. Calcium | 1.Kg | 12% |
2. GH | 35 kg | 14 | 23 | 2x 30 mg | 2. Multivitamins | 2. Lean body mass (kg) | 28% | |||||
3. Placebo + GH | 35.4 kg | 15 | 27.6 | 0 | ||||||||
3. Placebo | 32.3 kg | 15 | 26.3 | 7% | ||||||||
Halmi 1986 [26] | 32-45 days | Clinical | Restricting/ Binge-purge | 1. AH | 79 (IBW) | 23 | 20.56 | Amitryptyline | Inpatient | Â | 1. Days to target weight | n.m. |
2. AD | 77 (IBW) | 24 | 160 mg (max) | 2. Average kg gain/day | ||||||||
3. Placebo | 75 (IBW) | 25 | Â | |||||||||
Hill 2000 [27] | 28 days | Clinical | Restricting/ Binge-purge | 1.GH | 14 | 7 | 14.5 | Recombinant human growth hormone | Inpatient | 1. Standard treatment | 1. Average kg gain/day | n.m. |
2. Placebo | 15 | 8 (1 male) | 15 | 0.05 mg | ||||||||
1st Author, Year | Length of RCT | Recruitment | Anorexia type | Treatment conditions | Baseline mean weight a | N | Age | Type | Setting | Adjunctive treatments | Weight outcome measures | Drop-out |
Kafantaris 2011 [28] | 10 weeks | Clinical | Restricting | 1. AP | 16.9 | 10 | 17.1 | Olanzapine | Outpatient and inpatient | 1. Individual medication | 1. BMI | 30% |
2. Placebo | 16 | 10 | 2.5 mg | 2. Psychotherapy | 2.%MBW | 20% | ||||||
5 mg | 3. Family therapy | |||||||||||
7.5 mg | 4. Nutritional therapy | |||||||||||
10 mg | ||||||||||||
Lacey 1980 [29] | n.m. | Clinical | Restricting/ Binge-purge | 1. AD | 40.6 (kg) | 8 | n.m. | Clomipramine | Inpatient | 1. Individual psychotherapy | 1. Kg | 25% |
2. Placebo | 37.7 (kg) | 8 | 50 mg | 2. Caloric repletion | 2. Mean kg gain | 12% | ||||||
3. Rate kg gain/day | ||||||||||||
Miller 2011 [30] | 12 months | Community and clinical | Restricting/ Binge-purge | 1. OM/ H | 17.8 | 20 | 25.2 | Risedronate/Testosterone | Outpatient | Â | 1. Kg | 23% |
2. OM | 17.6 | 20 | 25.3 | 35 mg/ 150 mg | 2. Lean body mass | |||||||
3. H | 17.5 | 19 | 27.1 | |||||||||
4. Placebo | 17.9 | 18 | 26.9 | |||||||||
Misra 2011 [31] | 18 months | Community and clinical | Restricting/ Binge-purge | 1. H | 17.4 | 55 | 16.5 | Fysiologic estrogen replacement | Outpatient | 1. Behavior therapy | 1. Kg | 56% |
2. Placebo | 55 | 100 mg | 2. BMI | 54% | ||||||||
3. Fat mass | ||||||||||||
4. Lean mass | ||||||||||||
Strokosch 2006 [32] | 13x28 days | Clinical | Restricting/ Binge-purge | 1. H | 17.9 | 61 | 15.2 | Norgestimate/ Ethinyl Estradiol | Outpatient | Â | 1. Kg | 34% |
2. Placebo | 17.6 | 62 | 15.1 | 180-250 mg/ 35 mg | 2. BMI | 21% | ||||||
Vandereycken 1984 [33] | 2x3 weeks | Clinical | Restricting/ Binge-purge | 1. AP | 40.4 (kg) | 9 | 23.2 | Sulpiride | Inpatient | 1. Uniform therapeutic programme | 1. Daily g change | n.m. |
2. Placebo | 38.3 (kg) | 9 | 23.7 | 300 or 400 mg | ||||||||
Walsh 2006 [34] | 1 year | Community and clinical | Restricting/ Binge-purge | 1. AD | 15.4 | 49 | 22.4 | Fluoxetine | Outpatient | 1. CBT | 1. BMI | 57% |
2. Placebo | 44 | 24.2 | 20 mg to 60 mg | 2. Family therapy | 57% | |||||||
3. Medication monitoring |